• Support
  • Log In
  • Sign Up
ANZIIF Logo
Go back
Professional Development

Need help with professional development?

Contact Support

View by Kind
Go back
View by Kind
Short Courses Qualifications Skills Units Compliance Webinars Events Articles Videos Activities Whitepapers Ask an Expert
View by Sector
Go back
View by Sector
Claims General Insurance Insurance Broking Reinsurance Risk Management Life and Retirement Income
All Professional Development The Journal Recognition of Prior Learning Your Career in Insurance
Studying with ANZIIF
Go back
Studying with ANZIIF Enrol Academic Calendar Assessments FNS20 Training Package Student Support
For Companies
Go back
For Companies Train your staff Life Insurance Professional Standards General Insurance Claims Handling Framework Reference books Government Training Incentives
Go back
Membership

Need help with your membership?

Contact Support

Member Tools
Go back
Member Tools
Login Become a member Renew or Reinstate your membership
Members Centre - Professional Development
About membership
Go back
About membership
Your Membership Guide Member Levels Benefits Certified Insurance Professionals Digital Badge Member Directory
Scholarships and Awards
Go back
Scholarships and Awards
Australian Industry Awards New Zealand Industry Awards Academic Awards Lloyds Scholarship Turks Bright Light Award ICNZ and ANZIIF Scholarship
Go back
About ANZIIF

ANZIIF is the leading membership, training and professional development organisation for the insurance and finance industry in the Asia-Pacific region. We partner with a broad range of organisations and government to provide services that support professional excellence. We help enhance standards and improve community understanding of insurance and finance.

Overview
Go back
Overview History Boards and Councils Annual Reports Media Governance Corporate Sponsorship Partners Careers at ANZIIF Contact
Community Initiatives
Go back
Community Initiatives
Your Career in Insurance Careers in Insurance Corporate Supporter Making a Difference Awards Donna Walker Awards Life Insurance Professional Standards General Insurance Claims Handling Framework Generation i
ANZIIF Logo
Professional Development Whitepapers
Whitepaper
0.25CIP Points

Depreciation in business interruption insurance — A misunderstood concept

LF ONG — Chartered Insurance Practitioner, Arbitrator & Mediator
19 Nov 2024 - Reading time 60 minutes
Claims General Insurance
DEPRECIATION IN BUSINESS INTERRUPTION INSURANCE

 

Depreciation per se is neither a fixed cost nor a variable cost. In essence, depreciation is an optional cost, insurable as an item of the policy, at the sole discretion of the proposer/insured.

Main stream insurance practitioners would be horrified to regard depreciation other than a fixed cost because many, if not all, have been programmed to believe, like their predecessors, including those living in a bubble, the mantra that depreciation is part of the standing charges.

The prerogative to insure depreciation, or not, as an optional cost rests with the proposer/insured. Depreciation can be insured as an item on a limit of liability basis much like, inter alia, Additional Increase in Cost of Working and accountants’ charges/fees [1] which are not subject to underinsurance.

Depreciation, as an optional cost, is a novel and innovative concept in Business Interruption insurance, has never been explored at all.

Introduction

This technical paper, Understanding depreciation in Business Interruption insurance — A misunderstood concept, is a study of the meaning, practice, process and application of depreciation as an optional Cost in the Business Interruption insurance. 

It is appreciated that the concept of depreciation as an optional cost is totally against the norm of the Business Interruption insurance practice and would likely face considerable challenges from all angles.

An open mind is what is required for an understanding of this concept of depreciation as an optional cost for the learning curve. 

The awakening that depreciation is an optional cost stemmed from an actual Business Interruption insurance claim dispute following a fire outbreak at a manufacturing plant complex managed by a public listed corporation (the Claimant) against the Underwriter (the Respondent) under a Business Interruption insurance policy (the BI policy). It was arbitrated by a three-man arbitral Tribunal [2] (the Tribunal) whose Award was in favour of the Claimant, 

For reasons of confidentiality and privacy, the identities of the parties and Tribunal members as well as the date of fire and location of the palm oil mill could not be divulged. 

In a nutshell, the Tribunal, after hearing lengthy and protracted testimonies of expert witnesses and reviewing voluminous documentary evidence including bundles of authorities, held ipso facto cognizance to the fact that depreciation is not a fixed cost [3] (hereinafter referred to as standing charge), for the purpose of the Gross Profit [4].

The short story is that by including depreciation to the standing charges, the rate of gross profit by definition would be inflated up to an unrealistic level which was not cogently reflective of the Business insured. For this purpose, depreciation was regarded as an item suitably located in the specified working expenses (“SWE”). 

It has to be mentioned here that an Arbitral Award [5] is a private alternative dispute resolution (ADR) settlement between the contractual parties in dispute and is not regarded as a stare decisis (legal precedent), notwithstanding due process of law had been fully complied with, throughout the proceedings, in accordance with the Malaysian Arbitration Act 2005 (Act 646) by three eminent jurists whose grounds of decision are worth its weight in gold.

Download the full paper



[1] Additional Increase in Cost of Working and Accountants’ Fees/Charges are actually Optional items insurable at the discretion of the Proposer/Insured.

[2] The Tribunal comprised a London-based practicing Queen Counsel/Senior Barrister who is also a Law Professor, a former Malaysian Court of Appeal judge and a former Malaysian High Court judge.

[3] Fixed costs and Standing charges are synonymous.

[4] Gross Profit comprised Fixed Costs (Standing Charges) and Net Profit.

[5] Similar decision on Depreciation was reached by the NSW CA in Mobis Parts Australia Pty Ltd v XL Insurance SE [2018]. see Ibid, 12

This is Worth

0.25 CIP Points

Login to Collect Points & Comment
What are CIP Points? About ANZIIF Membership
Professional Development

Related Resources

  • Whitepaper
    0.25 CIP Points

    Machinery Breakdown Exclusion 9 Wear and Tear as Prescribed and not Otherwise

    The ‘wear and tear’ exclusion found in machinery breakdown policies is not well understood in the in
    22 Feb 2019
  • Premium

    Article
    0.25 CIP Points

    Business Interruption test case set for appeal in Federal Court

    After a major victory for insurers, the second of Australia’s business interruption test cases is se
    3 Nov 2021
    4 min read
  • Premium

    Activity
    0.5 CIP Points

    Business Interruption Fundamentals

    What happens when a business is interrupted by an unforeseen event? How does a business survive when
    3 Jul 2019
  • Skills Unit
    10 CIP Points

    Business interruption loss adjustment

    General Insurance, Claims, Insurance Broking

    Business interruption loss adjustment

    General Insurance, Claims, Insurance Broking
    AUD $460
  • Premium

    Article
    0.25 CIP Points

    Industry shares Business Interruption claims learnings

    Sedgwick’s Rodney Milford recently joined a panel of insurance experts in an ANZIIF webinar on the t
    9 Jun 2021
    5 min read
  • Journal
    0.25 CIP Points

    Putting business interruption cover to the test

    COVID-19 has had varying implications for business interruption insurance across the globe. At least
    17 Dec 2020
  • Your comment has been successfully posted

    Comments

    Loading comments

    Remove Comment

    Are you sure you want to delete your comment?
    This cannot be undone.

    kitchen sink logo
    • About
    • Professional Development
    • Membership
    • Compliance
    • Contact Us
    • Enrol
    • Become a Member
    • Login
    • Privacy Statement
    • Terms & Conditions

    © Copyright The Australian and New Zealand Institute of Insurance and Finance Inc. 2021

    RTO NO. 3596