• Support
  • Log In
  • Sign Up
ANZIIF Logo
Go back
Professional Development

Need help with professional development?

Contact Support

View by Kind
Go back
View by Kind
Short Courses Qualifications Skills Units Compliance Webinars Events Articles Videos Activities Whitepapers Ask an Expert
View by Sector
Go back
View by Sector
Claims General Insurance Insurance Broking Reinsurance Risk Management Life and Retirement Income
All Professional Development The Journal Recognition of Prior Learning Your Career in Insurance
Studying with ANZIIF
Go back
Studying with ANZIIF Enrol Academic Calendar Assessments FNS20 Training Package Student Support
For Companies
Go back
For Companies Train your staff Life Insurance Professional Standards General Insurance Claims Handling Framework Reference books Government Training Incentives
Go back
Membership

Need help with your membership?

Contact Support

Member Tools
Go back
Member Tools
Login Become a member Renew or Reinstate your membership
Members Centre - Professional Development
About membership
Go back
About membership
Your Membership Guide Member Levels Benefits Certified Insurance Professionals Digital Badge Member Directory Pro Rata 2025
Scholarships and Awards
Go back
Scholarships and Awards
Australian Industry Awards New Zealand Industry Awards Academic Awards Lloyds Scholarship Turks Bright Light Award ICNZ and ANZIIF Scholarship
Go back
About ANZIIF

ANZIIF is the leading membership, training and professional development organisation for the insurance and finance industry in the Asia-Pacific region. We partner with a broad range of organisations and government to provide services that support professional excellence. We help enhance standards and improve community understanding of insurance and finance.

Overview
Go back
Overview History Boards and Councils Annual Reports Media Governance Corporate Sponsorship Partners Careers at ANZIIF Contact
Community Initiatives
Go back
Community Initiatives
Your Career in Insurance Careers in Insurance Corporate Supporter Making a Difference Awards Donna Walker Awards Life Insurance Professional Standards General Insurance Claims Handling Framework Generation i
ANZIIF Logo
Professional Development Articles
Article
0.25CIP Points

Dealing with worst-case loss in multinational and industrial projects

Paul May — Chartered Loss Adjuster
30 Jun 2025 - Reading time 8 minutes
Insurance Broking Claims Risk Management Reinsurance
Worst case loss oil spill Paul MAY

 

You’ve probably heard the phrase, “Hope for the best, prepare for the worst.”

Personally, I find that too passive. When dealing with major risks and catastrophic losses, I believe in something simpler and far more practical: Plan for the worst.

Drawing on my experience across more than 90 countries over 50 years, I want to share some of the lessons I’ve learned in dealing with worst-case scenarios — and how we can better avoid, mitigate, and recover from them.

Today, I’ll touch on four essential areas: Risk Registers, Decision-Making, Strategic Opportunity, and Insurance Companies.

Risk Registers

I’ve never had much confidence in Risk Registers as they’re often used — overly reliant on probability models and far too static. I prefer the term Risk Radar — something dynamic that’s reviewed daily, not quarterly.

Take Fukushima. The tsunami that overwhelmed the plant exceeded their models by nearly 10 metres. Their assumptions simply weren’t challenged hard enough.

Similarly, I once worked a US$100 million environmental claim in South America. A joint venture had bought into ageing infrastructure in Bolivia.

Their Risk Register flagged oil leaks as probable but assumed low-cost exposure. When a pipeline failed over a river, we saw a massive oil slick stretch across 200km of farmland and shoreline. Cleanup took nearly two years.

The lesson? Don’t treat Risk Registers as gospel. Involve outsiders. Question everything — especially the “rare” and “never-before” scenarios.

Decision-Making Protocols

After a massive explosion at a Finnish property and business site, we spent four weeks trying to move the recovery forward — only to realise the people we were engaging had no authority to make real decisions.

It wasn’t until we asked for their internal governance in writing that we discovered a major shareholder held the final say. Once he was at the table, things moved quickly.

Worst-case planning must involve your board and insurers from the outset — not as an afterthought.

I always encourage clients to run dry-run drills, mapping out roles, timelines, and protocols for everything from supplier coordination to interim funding. You’re vulnerable in a crisis — and you need everyone aligned.

Strategic Opportunity

Not all losses are purely destructive. I worked with a major glass manufacturer in Asia after their only kiln suffered a catastrophic failure.

The board and I explored their options, and it turned out relocating to a neighbouring country made far more sense — better logistics, lower labour costs.

The original site? It was redeveloped into luxury apartments. They ended up with a new facility for less than the rebuild cost.

Sometimes, a worst-case scenario is a hidden strategic inflection point — if you’re willing to reimagine what’s possible.

Insurance Companies

Now, onto the delicate topic of insurers. For a relatively modest premium, an insurer assumes significant risk.

But come claim time, it’s not uncommon to encounter individuals who want to retroactively underwrite the policy:

“We never intended to cover that,” or “This equipment isn’t state of the art — why pay full value?”
These responses can threaten your recovery.

That’s why I encourage strong, transparent relationships. Keep your insurer informed, invite them to your crisis simulations, and agree on claims protocols in advance.

Be clear about interim payments, dispute processes, and roles — especially when reinsurers are involved. Often, your claim is in the hands of someone sitting in London, Munich, Paris, or New York.

I remember a terrorist bombing at a Central Bank that damaged nearby financial institutions.

I went on national television to assure the public that Lloyd’s and the reinsurers were committed to funding reconstruction.

It helped prevent a potential run on the banks — a liquidity crisis we couldn’t afford.

And if your policy is written in English, but your dispute resolution is local — say, in Finnish — have clarification sessions in both languages. Trust me, it matters.

One Final Note on Cyber Risk

Cyber threats are now very real worst-case scenarios. When attackers lock you out of your own systems, digital plans are useless.

Keep printed protocols. Use battery-powered satellite systems like Starlink. And make sure your insurer provides emergency offline contact details.

When Spain suffered a nationwide outage, Starlink users stayed connected. In a crisis, small decisions like that can make all the difference.

Over my career, I’ve seen just how devastating worst-case losses can be — but I’ve also seen how the best-prepared organisations bounce back stronger.

Planning for the worst isn’t pessimism. It’s survival.

Adapted from Paul May’s 2025 presentation to 100 members of the Risk Management Group of Project Professionals in Finland.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Paul May, LLB (Hons), MBA, FCII, FCILA, AdipC, DipAIS, CFIRM, MAE, FUEDI-ELAE, FIFAA
Chartered Loss Adjuster | Chartered Insurance Risk Manager | Court Expert

Paul May has worked in the Finnish multinational insurance market since 1995, bringing over 50 years of global experience in claims adjusting and arbitration across more than 90 countries.

A Chartered Loss Adjuster, Chartered Insurance Risk Manager, and practising Court Expert, May holds a Law degree, an MBA, and several postgraduate qualifications.

He leads the Concordia Global Network and is a Senior Fellow at City University, London.

Outside of work, he enjoys running, cycling, and sailing, having logged over 110,000 kilometres as an Offshore Commercial Yachtmaster.

This is Worth

0.25 CIP Points

Login to Collect Points & Comment
What are CIP Points? About ANZIIF Membership
Professional Development

Related Resources

  • Journal
    0.25 CIP Points

    Navigating natural catastrophes and man-made risks

    As the frequency of natural catastrophes and man-made risks increases, there is no room for complace
    5 Dec 2024
    20 min read
  • Premium

    Article
    0.25 CIP Points

    DEEP DIVE: Progress and pitfalls as New Zealand insurers navigate CoFI

    New Zealand insurers have recognised the significance of CoFI, and are taking the opportunity to rea
    29 May 2025
    8 min read
  • Premium

    Activity
    0.5 CIP Points

    Cyber resilience

    What do you need to do to protect yourself and your organisation from a cyber attack? Would your org
    30 Jan 2024
    20 min read
  • Premium

    Video
    0.75 CIP Points

    Webinar: Vulnerability — Code Protections and Support

    Join representatives of the IBCCC and GICGC in this on-demand webinar as they unpack the topic of co
    28 Feb 2025
    60 min view
  • Your comment has been successfully posted

    Comments

    Loading comments

    Remove Comment

    Are you sure you want to delete your comment?
    This cannot be undone.

    kitchen sink logo
    • About
    • Professional Development
    • Membership
    • Compliance
    • Contact Us
    • Enrol
    • Become a Member
    • Login
    • Privacy Statement
    • Terms & Conditions

    © Copyright The Australian and New Zealand Institute of Insurance and Finance Inc. 2021

    RTO NO. 3596