• Support
  • Log In
  • Sign Up
ANZIIF Logo
Go back
Professional Development

Need help with professional development?

Contact Support

View by Kind
Go back
View by Kind
Short Courses Qualifications Skills Units Compliance Webinars Events Articles Videos Activities Whitepapers Ask an Expert
View by Sector
Go back
View by Sector
Claims General Insurance Insurance Broking Reinsurance Risk Management Life and Retirement Income
All Professional Development The Journal Recognition of Prior Learning Your Career in Insurance
Studying with ANZIIF
Go back
Studying with ANZIIF Enrol Academic Calendar Assessments FNS20 Training Package Student Support
For Companies
Go back
For Companies Train your staff Life Insurance Professional Standards General Insurance Claims Handling Framework Reference books Government Training Incentives
Go back
Membership

Need help with your membership?

Contact Support

Member Tools
Go back
Member Tools
Login Become a member Renew or Reinstate your membership
Members Centre - Professional Development
About membership
Go back
About membership
Your Membership Guide Member Levels Benefits Certified Insurance Professionals Digital Badge Member Directory
Scholarships and Awards
Go back
Scholarships and Awards
Australian Industry Awards New Zealand Industry Awards Academic Awards Lloyds Scholarship Turks Bright Light Award ICNZ and ANZIIF Scholarship
Go back
About ANZIIF

ANZIIF is the leading membership, training and professional development organisation for the insurance and finance industry in the Asia-Pacific region. We partner with a broad range of organisations and government to provide services that support professional excellence. We help enhance standards and improve community understanding of insurance and finance.

Overview
Go back
Overview History Boards and Councils Annual Reports Media Governance Corporate Sponsorship Partners Careers at ANZIIF Contact
Community Initiatives
Go back
Community Initiatives
Your Career in Insurance Careers in Insurance Corporate Supporter Making a Difference Awards Donna Walker Awards Life Insurance Professional Standards General Insurance Claims Handling Framework Generation i
ANZIIF Logo
Professional Development Articles
Article
0.25CIP Points

Beyond Terrorism - How can we reinforce the Re

Dr Chris Wallace — ARPC CEO and International Forum of Terrorism Risk Insurance Pools (IFTRIP) President 2020
11 Nov 2020 - Reading time 3 minutes
Reinsurance Risk Management Insurance Broking Claims
Beyond Terrorism How can we reinforce the Re

I propose that there are similarities between terrorism incidents and pandemics. 

Both of these systemic risks impact international travel, close borders and cause economic harm by shutting down businesses. 

Both of these systemic risks terrorise the community, and as individuals we don’t know when it will strike, and we fear its personal impact upon us.

FAILURE OF THE SECURITY ENVIRONMENT

My colleague Gordon Woo at RMS describes often terrorism reinsurance schemes as 'insurance against the failure of the security environment'.

Ultimately, terrorism pools are the insurance against a terrorist attack. 

The impact of an attack is influenced by the negative drivers of terrorism such as social disadvantage and unrest but also the risk mitigation features of the security environment which prevents these events from occurring.

RISK MITIGATION WORKS

For example, In Australia, we have had 18 foiled attacks since 2014, which shows that risk mitigation through the security environment works.

The same applies for the pandemic. 

We have health and social disadvantage that can drive pandemic outbreaks, but the health security environment helps to mitigate pandemic risk by identifying (through testing) and controlling the spread of disease (through contact tracing and hopefully vaccines).

I think there are strong shared themes between pandemic and terrorism with regard to their terrorising effect on society, the economic harm caused, and that these impacts are influenced by the health and security environments. 

Therefore, a declared pandemic is similar in process to a declared terrorist incident. Both can be declared. Both have aspects of social disruption and risk mitigation through government.

PUBLIC PRIVATE PARTNERSHIPS

Importantly, they both suit public private risk sharing mechanisms.

A public/private pool for pandemic (and other systemic risks) could help support the reputation of the insurance industry by helping it to remain relevant to our society.

We are seeing pandemic risk excluded from insurance policies, it is becoming an excluded peril much like terrorism. 

It is a challenge for the insurance industry to protect its capital through excluding systemic risks but to provide value to customers who need cover. 

The important focus on testing the effectiveness of pandemic exclusions needs to be balanced with other solutions to address the risk so that the insurance industry remains relevant.

REPUTATIONAL IMPACTS

I worry about the reputational impacts to the insurance industry. 

Insurers do not have the capital to cover pandemic risk, but it could be confusing for policyholders and having a risk transfer process can only help to build the importance and value of private insurance.

Terrorism pools could be repurposed for pandemic or other systemic risks.

A terrorism and pandemic scheme could provide certainty to policyholders that cover will be provided and it would be beneficial to the insurance industry so long as there is also risk transfer. Such a scheme would mean that insurance is relevant during a pandemic. 

It would also encourage businesses to buy insurance.

CHALLENGES TO OVERCOME

But there remain many challenges in providing pooled cover for pandemic.

The biggest problem with insuring pandemic is the rapid speed and the massive scale of the financial response that is needed. 

Many schemes have state guarantees that would be inadequate for the sheer scale of pandemic. 

Governments have quite rightly focused on providing fiscal stimulus for pandemic relief measures to save jobs and businesses, these have included subsidies to businesses and unemployed.

An effective pandemic business interruption response ideally would target small business, have a time limited duration, and be simple or front-end paid.

A traditional business interruption insurance payment after the event will not deliver the support needed. A targeted, fast and simple defined benefit for pandemic peril would target the support where it is needed most.

LIMITED APPETITE

Reinsurers have limited appetite for terrorism, and it is beneficial for them to participate in the retrocession reinsurance programs run by pools. The pools offer reinsurers a homogenous pool of risks and allows them to participate and limit their exposure to each country. The same could apply to pandemic risk.

In a pandemic pool, I expect there would also be limited retrocession appetite. 

However, pools enable reinsurers to choose to deploy their scarce capital to geographic regions and to limit their capacity. 

This limiting of capacity by size and region should enable a reinsurer to still participate in a limited way in supporting future pandemic pools which still diversifies their risk. Not every country experiences the pandemic in the same way.

A VALUABLE CONTRIBUTION

The relationships and infrastructure of terrorism pools are very valuable to our societies.

Pools have relationships with government, or often are a part of government. Pools have existing people, systems and processes that can be deployed in a crisis to other systemic risks.

Pools support the pooling of risk, bringing about community rating where risk rating makes premiums unaffordable for customers.

Pool retrocession programs also protect taxpayers and engage the private reinsurance industry in participation and capacity. 

COMPENSATION FOR GOVERNMENT

And finally, governments are often compensated for their risk bearing roles through the pools.

In conclusion, terrorism pools play an important public/private role and can extend the reinsurance sector into risk areas that are either uninsurable or unaffordable and where reinsurers may otherwise not be able to price or cover.

So the pool can reinforce the re.

This is Worth

0.25 CIP Points

Login to Collect Points & Comment
What are CIP Points? About ANZIIF Membership
Your comment has been successfully posted

Comments

Loading comments

Remove Comment

Are you sure you want to delete your comment?
This cannot be undone.

kitchen sink logo
  • About
  • Professional Development
  • Membership
  • Compliance
  • Contact Us
  • Enrol
  • Become a Member
  • Login
  • Privacy Statement
  • Terms & Conditions

© Copyright The Australian and New Zealand Institute of Insurance and Finance Inc. 2021

RTO NO. 3596